This may be a catchy title, but it should have read The Case Against Social Media. In fact, depending on how progressive your organization is, you probably have heard one of the following two party lines:
1) We need to block Facebook (and all Social Media) because it destroys productivity.
2) We need to spend significantly on Facebook (and all Social Media) because we need to "join the conversation."
Both are overly simplistic: here's why:
Social Media Destroys Productivity: It is true that spending time doing one activity usually means less time is available to do something else. But this argument about productivity makes the assumption that people, if left to themselves, will no longer meet deadlines, nor strive to improve in the eyes of their managers and clients. The truth is that the vast majority of people care deeply about doing a good job. Those who don't care would simply abuse something else if Social Media weren't around. And even if you accept the argument that blocking Social Media is the right thing to do, most people can access it directly through their smart phones instead. Social Media doesn't destroy productivity, people destroy productivity.
We "Must" Join the Conversation: Social Media provides a great window into the marketplace, allowing companies (and individuals) to connect directly with prospects, customers, and other stakeholders. Without full engagement (e.g., heavy investment), the organization is at a competitive disadvantage, and will grow more and more remote from the "reality" of what is happening. This argument doesn't take into account that at a certain point, the marginal benefit of "more" investment is very low, and the opportunity cost of spending more in Social Media (vs. somewhere else) may in fact be extremely high. Of course the organization must join the conversation, but the degree of engagement must be monitored and measured. And it must fit within the overall marketing strategy – not be bolted on after-the-fact.
In both of the above cases, Social Media success boils down to one factor: Management. It's not new technology that creates productivity issues – it's poor management that does. And it's uninformed management that allows Social Media to consume far too much time and/or budget. The Case Against Social Media probably should have read The Case Against Bad Management.
Action plan: How do you manage your own Social Media productivity? Carefully separate your personal Social Media "entertainment" time, from work tasks that need to use Social Media. Keep a log − you'll be surprised at what you learn.
Randall Craig is an expert on Social Media Strategy and Social Media Policy; to find out how his workshops, webinars, and keynotes can help your team or add to your event, contact him through www.RandallCraig.com, or by email at email@example.com.